Starship Smackdown!

[Evshell]

Hmmm... I was:

1. Galaxy
2. Sovereign
3. Defiant

Not too far off from BL

Yeah, it was a close one. However, unless my logic is incorrect, you were slightly in 2nd, as he guessed exactly on Galaxy, and only 1 away on Sovereign, whereas you were 2 away for Galaxy and 1 away for Sovereign. I had to go back to my PMs and verify I was not incorrect, but you actually sent me:
1. Galaxy
2. Defiant
3. Sovereign

[Athos]

Hmmm... I was:

1. Galaxy
2. Sovereign
3. Defiant

Not too far off from BL

Yeah, it was a close one. However, unless my logic is incorrect, you were slightly in 2nd, as he guessed exactly on Galaxy, and only 1 away on Sovereign, whereas you were 2 away for Galaxy and 1 away for Sovereign. I had to go back to my PMs and verify I was not incorrect, but you actually sent me:
1. Galaxy
2. Defiant
3. Sovereign

I was 2 away with the Galaxy and right on the money for the Sovereign.   It just depends upon what point system you assigned for each place.

[Jeff T]

Congratulations to Battle Lion for his victory in this first Smackdown.

The results stand as is... and we look forward to the next contest.

Thank you also to Evshell for presenting such an engaging activity that had all of us on the edge of our Captain's chair throughout this process that lasted for over eight months. 

Bravo!

[Kheren]

Indeed a great game full of suspense, surprises and info, not only about the ships themselves and the series but more importantly about each other. 

I feel we are all winners for now better knowing and appreciating one another.

Kudos Evshell! Hope something like that happens again!

[Niomo]

Maybe a bracket of Characters (Non-Captain)?

[Evshell]

Maybe a bracket of Characters (Non-Captain)?

That was my next plan... taking a few months off before tackling it though.

[Battle Lion]

I'm going to go ahead and submit my picks for that one now...

1. wesley crusher
2. Dr. Pulaski
3. Harry Kim

[Niomo]

I'm going to go ahead and submit my picks for that one now...

1. wesley crusher
2. Dr. Pulaski
3. Harry Kim

I'd blow up the starbase if they won.

Well, Harry Kim wasn't THAT bad, Kes was far worse.

[Athos]

Hmmm... I was:

1. Galaxy
2. Sovereign
3. Defiant

Not too far off from BL

Yeah, it was a close one. However, unless my logic is incorrect, you were slightly in 2nd, as he guessed exactly on Galaxy, and only 1 away on Sovereign, whereas you were 2 away for Galaxy and 1 away for Sovereign. I had to go back to my PMs and verify I was not incorrect, but you actually sent me:
1. Galaxy
2. Defiant
3. Sovereign

Woops...you're correct Evshell.  I was mistaken.  And thanks for coming up with the idea of the Smackdown and running the show.  As frustrating as it was at times, it's a great event.

Well guessed Battle Lion.