List of Flaws: Abram's take on Star Trek for upcoming panel

Discuss Star Trek, the reason we're all here! Star Trek themed forum games and best/worst polls are also welcome.

Re: List of Flaws: Abram's take on Star Trek for upcoming pa

Postby Storm Windfall » Fri May 09, 2014 5:46 pm

Great stuff, Kheren!,

Another thing I noted - after watching the TOS again - is that the actors really tried hard to emulate Nimoy, Shatner and the rest of the original actors instead of putting their own stamp on the characters. They failed miserably. Their acting, for me, look forced.

What I understand from a parallel or even an alternate universe are, that even though it may be the same person, the same name, there will be major differences between that universe and ours, between our, or their 'twins' or whatever over there. Different decisions have different outcomes. Here I say no, there I say yes. Their lives and their character should differ a lot from the Kirk et cie we know.

I don't know if anyone will understand what I am trying to say, but I had to say it! :P

(Kheren, you should write someone's biography. Your research is outstanding! Gonna miss you :( )
User avatar
Storm Windfall
Commodore
Commodore
 
Posts: 145
Joined: Sat Aug 10, 2013 9:18 am
Has thanked: 127 times
Been thanked: 169 times
Medals: 24
Lotus Fleet Medal of Honor (1) Fleet Admiral's Star (1) Lotus Fleet Legion of Honor (1) Lotus Fleet Heart of Sacrifice (1)
LF Ribbon of Excellence (1) Commendation Award 4 (1) Lotus Fleet Star Cross (1) Braintrust (1)
Command School Certified (1) Academy Graduate (1) Lotus Fleet Instructor Badge (1) Course Writer (1)
STO Lotus Fleet Thread Award (1) Audio Quiz Participant (1) Lotus Fleet Tour Ribbon (9) From the Ashes (1)

Re: List of Flaws: Abram's take on Star Trek for upcoming pa

Postby Kheren » Fri May 09, 2014 8:56 pm

Got it Storm... but apparently, Abrams, Orci & Kurtzman used it to justify throwing away real ST for their dumbed-down, morality-void, story-lacking, popcorn-science one... but in the process get completely confused between black holes and wormholes, time travel and quantum realities, Star Trek and Star Wars.

Doesn't take much research you know; like most Star Trek fans,  just look at the movies without switching off your brain.
Fleet XO - RP Director - Former Fleet Admiral, Operations CO, JAG and Ambassador - Former Captain of the USS Artemis and of the flagship USS Horizon - Current Captain of the USS Millennium

"In this galaxy, there is a mathematical probability of three million Earth-type planets. In all the universe, three million, million galaxies like this.
And in all of that... and perhaps more...
only one of each of us."


Dr Leonard H. McCoy
TOS Balance of Terror
User avatar
Kheren
Admiral
Admiral
 
Posts: 937
Joined: Mon Aug 06, 2012 9:40 pm
Location: Trois-Rivieres, Quebec, Canada
Has thanked: 451 times
Been thanked: 398 times
Medals: 43
Fleet Admiral's Star (1) Lotus Fleet Legion of Honor (1) Lotus Fleet Heart of Sacrifice (1) LF Ribbon of Excellence (1)
Commendation Award 5 (1) Commendation Award 4 (1) Lotus Fleet Star Cross (1) Command School Certified (1)
Academy Honor Graduate (1) Course Contributor (2) Newsletter (1) Media Contributions (1)
Artistry (1) STO Lotus Fleet Thread Award (1) Outstanding Post (1) Trivia Titan (1)
STO Open Beta (1) Fed Fleet Builder VIII (1) KDF Fleet Builder IV (1) Lotus Fleet Tour Ribbon (12)
RP Master (1) JOC Award (1) Junior Mission Specialist (1) Character Sacrifice (1)
Captive Starbase (1) Before the Storm (1) Borg War (1) Azimuth Horizon Crusade (1)
The Forgotten (1) From the Ashes (1) Brave New World (1)

Previous

Return to Star Trek Discussion

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 17 guests

cron